Your free QR code expired. The paper is fine.
Search for “free QR code expired” and you will find a lot of people who printed a menu, a wedding sign, or a product label during a trial, then watched the scan land on a page that asks them to upgrade. The code did not reach an expiry date. The account that owned the redirect did.
“Free” was a trial
The generators that push dynamic codes — the kind you can edit after printing, with a scan counter — give them away for a short window. QR Code Generator’s public materials describe 14 days. QRFY describes 7. When the window closes, dynamic codes stop redirecting to you. Static codes made on the same sites are a different object: the URL is inside the image, and their own help pages say those keep working.
That split is the whole trick, and it is not a secret. It is easy to miss on the way to “download PNG” because both results look like a black-and-white square.
How to tell which one you have
Scan it and read the domain, or paste the address into the checker. A code that contains qrco.de, l.ead.me, qrfy.io, qr1.be, or another host on that list is a redirect someone else can turn off. A code that contains your domain is static. It did not expire. If it fails, the failure is the website or the print.
There is a third case. A Bitly link (bit.ly) is a shortener, not the same product as QR Code Generator’s dynamic codes, even though Bitly owns that product. Bitly’s links are not on a 14-day clock. They do die if the link is deleted, and free-plan rules have been tightened before. The checker says so, instead of lumping them in with the trial codes.
Paying them again versus reprinting
Upgrading the original account often switches the old codes back on. That is the least wasteful fix if you can log in and you are willing to keep paying. It does not change the bargain: the squares on the paper are rented.
Reprinting is the fix when the account is gone, the trial data was deleted, or you do not want the same bill next year. A static reprint is free on the generator. An editable reprint is a one-time credit on QR for Keeps — $12 for three, $29 for fifteen — and the redirect is what the ten-year pledge covers. The other lifetime offer we see advertised is $49 per code. Subscription plans in this category are commonly $15–45 a month. Those numbers move; check them. The shape of the deal is the part that keeps biting people.
What the service page is doing
The scan still resolves. It resolves to the vendor, who uses that moment to sell the subscription that turns your destination back on. Your content is often still in the account, which is useful if you upgrade and useless if you wanted the paper to keep working on its own. Nothing in the image file holds a copy of your URL. That is the point of a dynamic code, and it is the entire risk.
If you are about to print a new run, decide first whether the destination will change. If it will not, do not take a dynamic trial “just in case”. Bake the URL in. If it will, pay for a redirect you are not renting by the month. The longer version of that choice is a QR code without a subscription.